Disciplinary Inquiries and Natural Justice: A Civil Servant's Guide to Show-Cause Notices, Charge Sheets and Inquiry Defects
A civil servant can be penalised only through the procedure prescribed in the disciplinary rules: for federal employees the Civil Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 2020, and in Sindh the Sindh Civil Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 1973. Where the charges are denied and depend on evidence, the Supreme Court expects a regular inquiry with a charge sheet, a statement of allegations, a chance to cross-examine witnesses and a personal hearing. A penalty imposed in breach of natural justice is commonly set aside, often with a direction for a de novo inquiry.

Most service appeals are decided on what happened during the disciplinary proceedings, not on what happened in the office. A vague charge, a skipped inquiry or a report the officer never saw can undo a dismissal years later; equally, a department that follows its own rules carefully is rarely overturned on the facts.
This guide walks through the stages of a departmental inquiry under the federal and Sindh rules, the natural justice requirements the courts read into them, and the defects that most often lead to a penalty being set aside. If you are looking for the best service lawyer in Karachi because a charge sheet has just arrived, the most useful work in the first week is checking whether the allegations are specific enough to answer and whether the rules require a regular inquiry in your case.
Which rules apply: federal, Sindh, or neither
Section 16 of the Civil Servants Act, 1973 makes a federal civil servant liable to "prescribed disciplinary action and penalties in accordance with the prescribed procedure". That procedure is now in the Civil Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 2020 (S.R.O. 1331(I)/2020, notified on 11 December 2020), which repealed the Government Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 1973. Proceedings already pending at that date continued under the old rules.
Provincial civil servants in Sindh are governed by the Sindh Civil Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 1973, framed under the Sindh Civil Servants Act, 1973 and amended many times since. The two sets of rules share the same architecture but differ on timelines, on who decides, and on some safeguards, so the first job is always to identify which set applies.
Not everyone in government employment is a "civil servant". The federal definition in section 2(1)(b) excludes persons on deputation from a province or other authority, contract and work-charged employees, and "workers" under the Factories Act, 1934. Employees of statutory corporations and autonomous bodies are usually governed by their own service regulations, and their remedy is different (see the forum section below and our guide to Service Tribunal jurisdiction under Article 212).
The show-cause notice, charge sheet and statement of allegations
Both sets of rules allow action on four broad grounds: inefficiency, misconduct, corruption (including assets disproportionate to known income) and subversive activities or disclosure of official secrets (rule 3 of each). The paperwork the officer receives depends on the route the authority chooses.
- If an inquiry is ordered, the officer receives a charge sheet with a statement of allegations. Under the federal rules the charges must be communicated within 14 days of the inquiry order and the officer has 10 to 14 days to file a written defence (rule 9). Under the Sindh rules the authorised officer frames the charge and the defence is due within a period of not less than 7 and not more than 14 days, and the accused must state whether he wants to be heard in person (rule 6(1)).
- If the inquiry is dispensed with, the officer receives a show-cause notice setting out the charges and the proposed penalty. The federal rules give 10 to 14 days to reply and require the authority to decide within 30 days, after a personal hearing (rule 7). The Sindh rules require written notice of the proposed action and its grounds and a reasonable opportunity to show cause (rule 5(3)).
The charges matter more than anything else in the file. The Supreme Court has held, in a 2024 order in a Punjab police officer's appeal reported in the press, that departmental action must stay within the allegations in the show-cause notice; a penalty upheld on a ground the officer was never asked to answer was set aside and remanded. Vague charges, such as "negligence in official duties" with no date, document or transaction, are a recognised ground of challenge, because an officer cannot meaningfully defend an allegation he cannot identify.
Regular inquiry or no inquiry: when the department may dispense with it
The rules let the authority decide whether an inquiry is necessary (federal rules 6 and 7; Sindh rule 5(2)). That discretion is not unlimited. The courts have repeatedly drawn the line at disputed facts: where the officer denies the charge and the allegation can only be proved by recording evidence, a regular inquiry is expected.
The High Court of Sindh applied this in Muhammad Akram v. Federation of Pakistan (C.P. No. D-4800 of 2016, decided 29 April 2022), relying on Abdul Qayyum v. D.G. Project Management Organization (2003 SCMR 1110) for the proposition that a regular inquiry may be dispensed with only in exceptional circumstances, and holding that a fact-finding inquiry cannot take its place once the charges are denied. The dismissal was set aside and a regular inquiry ordered.
The Supreme Court has taken the same line more recently. In Malik Muhammad Ramzan v. Commissioner Sargodha Division (C.P. No. 2768-L of 2022), a Punjab case decided under that province's PEEDA Act, 2006 but stating a general principle, a dismissal for alleged embezzlement was set aside because no show-cause notice was proved to have been served and no inquiry was actually held; the Court ordered reinstatement and a de novo inquiry. In a 2025 case concerning PASSCO, a federal corporation, a bench headed by Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah described the inquiry as part of the protection given by Articles 9, 10A and 14 of the Constitution, not a formality.
There are genuine exceptions. Both sets of rules exclude the normal procedure where an officer is dismissed or removed on the basis of a criminal conviction, or where the authority records in writing that giving an opportunity to show cause is not reasonably practicable (federal rule 13; Sindh rule 8). The same line of authority accepts that where the facts are admitted, or no evidence needs to be recorded to prove the charge, a regular inquiry may be dispensed with. The exception must be justified on the record, not assumed.
Inside the inquiry: inquiry officer, evidence, cross-examination and ex parte proceedings
An inquiry officer or an inquiry committee has the powers of a civil court under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 to summon witnesses, take evidence on oath and require documents (federal rule 12; Sindh rule 7). The key procedural guarantees are similar in both regimes, but the timelines differ:
| Step | Federal (E&D Rules, 2020) | Sindh (E&D Rules, 1973) |
|---|---|---|
| Written defence to charge sheet | 10 to 14 days (rule 9) | 7 to 14 days (rule 6(1)(b)) |
| Cross-examination of witnesses | Both sides may cross-examine (rule 10) | Accused may cross-examine witnesses against him (rule 6(2)) |
| Hearings and adjournments | Day to day; adjournment not over 7 days, reasons recorded | Day to day; adjournment not over one week, reasons recorded |
| Completion of inquiry | 60 days, extendable; report within 7 days (rule 10) | Report within 10 days of conclusion, or longer if allowed (rule 6(5)) |
| Representation by a lawyer | Not permitted at the departmental stage | Not permitted (rule 10-B) |
Under the federal rules, a departmental representative must attend with the record and present the department's case (rule 15). If the accused does not file a reply in time, the inquiry may proceed ex parte (rule 10(2)), and an accused who hampers the inquiry can be warned and the proceedings completed without him. The Sindh rules similarly allow the inquiry officer to record a finding and complete the inquiry where the accused obstructs it after a warning (rule 6(4)). A missed federal timeline does not by itself vitiate the inquiry (proviso to rule 10(7)).
Cross-examination is where many inquiries fail. In a 2025 judgment reported in Dawn, arising from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, the Supreme Court remanded a removal order for a de novo inquiry, noting that the accused had not been allowed to cross-examine a witness produced against him and that the authority must ensure its inquiry officer knows the basic rules. Statements recorded behind the accused's back and then relied on are a classic defect.
After the report: inquiry report, personal hearing and de novo inquiry
Under federal rule 16, the authority first examines whether the inquiry was conducted in accordance with the rules. If it was not, it may remand the case or order a de novo inquiry through a different inquiry officer or committee. If the charges are not proved, the officer is exonerated in writing. If they are proved, the authority issues a show-cause notice with a copy of the inquiry report, the officer has 10 to 14 days to reply and to say whether he wants a personal hearing, and the authority must decide within 30 days of the reply.
Under the Sindh rules, the authorised officer decides on the findings and either imposes a minor penalty or forwards the case with a recommendation to the authority for a major penalty (rule 5(4)). A proviso added in 1984 requires notice to the accused and a fortnight to reply before a penalty is imposed or recommended; the compilation published by the Services, General Administration and Coordination Department reads that proviso as requiring a copy of the inquiry report to accompany the notice. Orders must then be communicated to the accused.
Non-supply of the inquiry report is a recurring ground in service appeals, because an officer cannot answer findings he has not seen. The same is true of a personal hearing that is offered on paper but never actually given, or a final order that does not deal with the reply. For the range of penalties the authority can then impose, and how the Tribunal treats proportionality, see our guide to major and minor penalties.
Natural justice defects that most often defeat a penalty
The right to be heard was given constitutional weight in the civil service context in Pakistan v. Public at Large (PLD 1987 SC 304), where the Shariat Appellate Bench held that provisions allowing civil servants to be retired without being told the grounds or allowed to reply were repugnant to the Injunctions of Islam. Since 2010, Article 10A guarantees a fair trial and due process in the determination of civil rights and obligations; the Supreme Court explained the meaning of a fair trial in Suo Motu Case No. 4 of 2010 (PLD 2012 SC 553). In practice, the defects that succeed are concrete:
- Bias. An inquiry officer who is the complainant, a witness, or the officer's known adversary. In Malik Muhammad Ramzan the inquiry officer was also the complainant in the related criminal case.
- Mala fides. A second inquiry launched after an exoneration, or proceedings started immediately after the officer won a case against the department, invite scrutiny of motive.
- Findings beyond the charges or based on material never put to the officer.
- No cross-examination of the witnesses whose statements were relied on.
- Non-supply of the inquiry report or of the documents relied on.
- Wrong authority. A penalty imposed by an officer who is not the competent authority under the rules.
- Unreasoned final order that ignores the reply and the hearing.
On the other side, the department does not have to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. The Supreme Court's 2024 order mentioned above confirmed that the standard in departmental proceedings is the balance of probabilities, and the courts generally treat the competent authority as the judge of facts unless the procedure was unlawful or the finding rests on no evidence.
Absence from duty, wilful absence and criminal cases
Unauthorised absence is one of the most common charges, and one of the most frequently mishandled. Under the federal rules, where a charge of absence for more than one year is proved, the penalty must be compulsory retirement, removal or dismissal (proviso to rule 16(7)). That does not remove the need for proper proceedings: the charge still has to be framed, served and proved, and an ex parte inquiry is defensible only where notices were genuinely sent to the officer's known address.
Departments should also check what else the file says. In April 2026 the Supreme Court remanded a Ministry of Commerce dismissal to the Federal Service Tribunal because the same period of absence had been converted into leave without pay at the same time as the dismissal; keeping a dismissal for absence that had been regularised as leave was described as illogical. Officers, for their part, should keep proof of every leave application, medical certificate and joining report.
A pending criminal case does not automatically stop departmental proceedings. The federal rules say proceedings are not discontinued merely because the matter is sub judice, although the inquiry may be deferred in some situations. A conviction can lead to penalty without the normal procedure (federal rule 13; Sindh rule 8), but an acquittal does not automatically wipe out a departmental finding reached on different evidence and a lower standard.
Where to challenge a flawed inquiry, and when
A show-cause notice or charge sheet is not, by itself, usually open to challenge in court. In Suit No. 1862 of 2023, the High Court of Sindh refused an injunction against a show-cause notice issued to a police officer, finding the suit apparently barred by Article 212 of the Constitution and section 4 of the Sindh Service Tribunals Act, 1973, relying on Ali Azhar Khan Baloch v. Province of Sindh (2015 SCMR 456). The better course is to answer the charges fully, object to defects in writing at each stage, and build the record.
Once a final order is passed, a civil servant must first file a departmental appeal or representation (within 30 days under rule 10 of the Sindh rules; for federal employees, under the Civil Servants (Appeal) Rules, 1977) and then appeal to the Federal or Sindh Service Tribunal, which may confirm, set aside, vary or modify the order (section 5 of the Tribunals Acts). See our guides on the departmental appeal and on limitation and condonation of delay. Every inquiry defect should be raised in the departmental appeal itself.
Employees of statutory bodies who are not civil servants, but whose employer has statutory service rules, may instead invoke Article 199 before a Constitutional Bench of the High Court, as in Muhammad Akram. From a Tribunal judgment, a further appeal lies to the Supreme Court under Article 212(3) only if leave is granted on a substantial question of law of public importance. For an overview of the full sequence, see our civil service and Service Tribunal practice page.
Official sources
- Civil Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 2020 (S.R.O. 1331(I)/2020), gazette copy
- Sindh Civil Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 1973 (Sindh SGA&CD compilation)
- Civil Servants Act, 1973
- Sindh Service Tribunals Act, 1973 (High Court of Sindh)
- Muhammad Akram v. Federation of Pakistan, C.P. No. D-4800 of 2016 (High Court of Sindh, 29.04.2022)
- Law Reform Commission / SHC fortnightly digest (1-15 August 2025): Malik Muhammad Ramzan v. Commissioner Sargodha Division

Common questions
Can I take a lawyer to a departmental inquiry?
No. Both the federal Civil Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 2020 and the Sindh Civil Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 1973 bar representation by an advocate at the departmental stage. You can, however, take legal advice privately and have a lawyer help draft your written defence, your objections and your reply to the second show-cause notice.
What is the difference between a fact-finding inquiry and a regular inquiry?
A fact-finding or preliminary inquiry is an internal exercise to see whether there is a case at all, usually without the accused officer's participation. A regular inquiry follows a charge sheet and statement of allegations, records evidence in the officer's presence and allows cross-examination. A major penalty based only on a fact-finding report, where the charges were denied, is vulnerable on appeal.
My reply to the charge sheet is due but I have not been given the documents relied on. What should I do?
Ask for them in writing at once, listing each document mentioned in the statement of allegations, and file your reply within time anyway, recording that it is provisional because the documents were withheld. Keep proof of delivery of both letters. That record is often decisive later before the Service Tribunal.
Can the department hold a fresh inquiry after I have been exonerated?
Under federal rule 16 the authority may order a de novo inquiry through a different officer if it finds the first inquiry was not conducted in accordance with the rules. It should record reasons for doing so. A second inquiry on the same facts without any finding of procedural defect may be challenged as arbitrary or mala fide.
Is a show-cause notice alone enough to dismiss a civil servant?
Only where the rules permit the inquiry to be dispensed with and the authority has a proper basis for doing so, such as admitted facts or a criminal conviction. Where the officer denies the charges and they depend on evidence, the courts expect a regular inquiry. Even when no inquiry is held, the officer must receive written grounds, a chance to reply and, under the federal rules, a personal hearing.
What should a department do to make its disciplinary order hold up?
Frame specific charges, choose the right competent authority, hold a regular inquiry where facts are disputed, let the accused cross-examine witnesses, supply the inquiry report with the second show-cause notice, give a real personal hearing, and pass a reasoned order that deals with the reply. Most penalties set aside by the Tribunals fail on one of these steps rather than on the facts.
Can I go to the High Court against a charge sheet in Karachi?
Usually not, if you are a civil servant. The High Court of Sindh has treated suits against show-cause notices as barred by Article 212 of the Constitution and section 4 of the Sindh Service Tribunals Act, 1973. Your remedy is to defend the inquiry, then file a departmental appeal and, if needed, a Service Tribunal appeal against the final order.
This article is general information about Pakistani law and procedure, not legal advice for any specific matter. If this touches on something you're currently facing, get in touch and we'll advise on your facts directly.